Shipboard long-core
paleomagnetic measurements made during Leg 172 identified a reproducible pattern
of directional secular variation within oxygen isotope Stage 3 that could be
correlated between Sites 1061, 1062, and 1063, which span a distance of more
than 1200 km. Two intervals of excursional paleomagnetic directions were
identified at all three sites within Stage 3 and were labeled as excursions 3
and 3
.
New analysis of excursions 3
and 3
,
based on the shipboard measurements, new U-channel
paleomagnetic records of the excursions, and independently published discrete
sample paleomagnetic records of the same intervals all indicate that excursion 3
is not real; its directional variability is less than originally estimated and
not excursional. Excursion 3
is real and easily identified in both U-channel
and discrete sample measurements. The best U-channel
record of excursion 3
from Hole 1063C is almost identical to the best discrete sample paleomagnetic
records. The U-channel
records from Holes 1061B and 1061C are similar to one another but somewhat
different from the other records (more smoothed). We attribute that difference
to systematic biases in the U-channel
measurement process when large-amplitude, fast directional changes occur.