INTRODUCTION
The primary objective of Leg 185 was to determine the geochemical
composition of the sediments and upper volcanic section of oceanic crust
being subducted into the western Pacific arc system. These data are
required as part of the subduction equation, which involves quantifying
the inputs and outputs, both into the arc and back into the mantle, of the
subduction factory (Fig. 1). These processes are important, as it is in the
subduction factory that the majority of chemical recycling is currently
taking place on Earth. These "factories" were probably the main sites of
crustal production through geological time (Armstrong, 1968; Karig and
Kay, 1981; Reymer and Schubert, 1984; McLennan, 1988), and despite the
fact that there is good evidence for transport of fluid and melt from the
subducted plate to the arc system (Morris et al., 1990; Hawkesworth et
al., 1997; Elliott et al., 1997), there are few quantitative constraints on
the recycling equation and its effect on the dynamics of crust formation
and destruction. The ODP program since the late 1980s has, as a part of
several drilling legs, tackled this problem (see "Historical Perspectives"
section), but Leg 185 was the first ODP leg for which the objectives were
specifically applied to coring oceanic crust and sedimentary sections
representative of the different inputs into the subduction factory; in this
case the Mariana and Izu-Bonin arcs of the west Pacific ocean (Fig. 2).
Many of the key elements that are important in understanding crustal
growth (e.g. Th, rare earth elements [REEs], Ba, and Be) are sequestered in
the sedimentary column and in the uppermost oxidized portions of the
volcanic section of oceanic basement (K, B, U, CO2, and H2O). The input of
these and other elements may vary as a function of sediment composition
(Plank and Langmuir, 1998) or the nature of the volcanic basement
(Staudigel et al., 1986 ; Alt and Teagle, 1999). For example, the absence of
significant carbonate in the sediments may influence the CO2 content of
an arc. The presence of organic-rich sediments or hydrothermal sediment
may influence the input of metals in different arcs. Alkaline off-axis
volcanics and associated volcaniclastic sediments, when subducted, may
significantly affect the alkali inventory to the subduction factory.
The igneous section of ocean crust inherits many of its physical and
geochemical characteristics at the spreading ridge. Significant
differences in eruption style, ridge morphology, and structure occur
depending on the rate of spreading (see review in Perfit and Chadwick,
1998). Similarly, the hydrothermal systems vary as a function of the
longevity and depth of the magma chamber (e.g., Gillis, 1995; Haymon et
al., 1991), and, on average, the alteration characteristics and, therefore,
the geochemical inventory of crust, must vary as a function of spreading
rate. As crust ages and moves away from the spreading axis, it is initially
cooled by hydrothermal activity and later warms again as it equilibrates
with the geothermal gradient. The chemical changes occurring during this
transition are important, not only in controlling the compositions of the
oceans (Staudigel et al., 1986; Alt and Teagle, 1999), including the retro
actions between continental erosion and oceanic composition, but also in
fixing key elements that will later be recycled into the subduction
factory. Some of these elements will migrate into the arc crust, whereas
others will be recycled into the mantle, possibly to return to the oceanic
crust as hot-spot magma. Although the chemical maturation of crust must
continue for several tens of millions of years after its formation (Stein
and Stein, 1994) and probably throughout its history, the most significant
alteration is at the ridge axis and for about 10-30 m.y. following crustal
accretion (Staudigel et al., 1986; Alt et al., 1986; Alt et al., 1992).
In an analogous fashion, the history of sedimentation on the oceanic
crust as it transits different oceanic regimes will influence the
composition of the input into the subduction factory (Plank and Langmuir,
1998). The sedimentary sequence in subduction regimes in nonequatorial
zones will differ significantly in composition from those where the
oceanic crust has "resided" mainly in equatorial regimes. The presence of
intraplate volcanoes may result in a significant flux of volcaniclastic
material into the sedimentary sequence. This may have very different
characteristics in key isotope ratios, especially Pb, that the arc may
inherit or that may be recycled back into the mantle. When proximal to
active margins, the upper sediments may contain significant quantities of
terrigenous turbidites. As the oceanic plate approaches the trench, the
final contribution to the sedimentary pile will include ash from the
volcanic arc. For margins that are not accreting sediments, this
component will be recycled into the mantle or created beneath the forearc.
The oldest oceanic crust on Earth is subducting into the Izu-Mariana arc
system, and in addition to providing geochemical data to input into the
subduction equation, the two sites studied provide important geochemical
constraints on the nature and history of Mesozoic ocean crust. Both sites
are shown in Figure 2. Site 801 is in the Pigafetta Basin, which is in the
Jurassic Quiet Zone (JQZ) and is dated as ~170 Ma (Pringle, 1992). It is the
oldest crust drilled by ODP or the Deep Sea Drilling Project (DSDP). The
second site, Site 1149 in the Nadezhda Basin, is on the same flow line as
Site 801 but is on magnetic Anomaly M11 and, as such, has an estimated
age of ~135 Ma. Both sites originated at spreading centers in the Southern
Hemisphere and then migrated northward, but at different times and
durations. Thus, in addition to the "Subduction Factory experiment," Leg
185 scientists had an unparalleled opportunity to (1) assess the
paleoequatorial sedimentation history of the Pacific Ocean since Mesozoic
time, (2) place limits on the ages of the oldest magnetic anomalies in the
ocean basins, and (3) study the nature of the JQZ.
With the exception of relatively soft oozes and clays, drilling in
oceanic crust rarely recovers the entire sedimentary and igneous section;
thus, calculating the geochemical inventory is problematic. The gaps in
the data have to be filled in by combining detailed core description and
logging the drill hole both for physical parameters, such as resistivity,
porosity, and velocity, and for geochemical composition. In addition to the
regular inventory of ODP logs, the geochemical logging tool was used
during Leg 185.
The ultimate long-term goal of studies of the subduction factory is to
create a complete geochemical mass balance of the inputs, outputs, and
residues lost from the system. Geochemists and geophysicists argue
strongly for the recycling of oceanic crust and sediments to the mantle
(Hofmann, 1997; Van der Hilst et al., 1997). Given adequate control on the
subduction equation, it may ultimately be possible to identify the recycled
products of the factory, not only in the arc volcanoes, but as they reappear
as mantle plumes on the Earth's surface after being recycled into the
mantle. The Izu-Mariana system was chosen as the first of these studies
because it is relatively simple:
- It is characterized only by limited sediment accretion.
- It has a well-defined subduction geometry, which is relatively steep
in the Mariana arc, and penetrates the 670 km discontinuity and is
shallower in the Izu-Bonin arc (Van der Hilst et al. (1997).
- It has a wide aperture from forearc across the arc to the backarc.
- The region has already been the subject of ODP drilling in
serpentinite mounds associated with forearc dewatering (Leg 125;
Fryer, 1992) and has a well-studied deep-sea ash and volcanic
record (Legs 125 and 126)
Too often postcruise research on ODP samples produces a data set
dispersed among many individual investigators. During Leg 185 a novel
approach was that the investigators chose to work on a common set of
samples. The geochemical database thus developed for Leg 185 will be a
unique contribution to the Geochemical Earth Reference Model (GERM) and
to the MARGINS Program initiative, and the communal samples will be a
legacy of the leg. The two sites drilled during Leg 185 provide critical
information on the input to the "subduction factory" system. In particular,
Hole 801C, now at a depth of 934 mbsf remains as an ODP legacy hole in
the oldest ocean crust on Earth.
An important objective not directly related to the problem of
geochemical recycling involved the study of the deep biosphere at both
sites. Bacteria have been located in association with ridge axis
hydrothermal systems within the sediment column as deep as 800 m
(Parkes et al., 1994). In addition, textural evidence suggests that bacteria
living off nutrients associated with basaltic glass alteration may thrive
in the basaltic crust (Thorseth et al., 1995; Fisk et al., 1998; Furnes and
Staudigel, 1999). The fascinating possibility that bacterial activity may
persist in oceanic crust as old and as deep as that at Sites 801 and 1149
provided the motivation for sampling the basement for bacteria culturing
and DNA extraction in the search for extremophile life. To control the
extent of contamination from surface waters, drilling mud, and drilling
tools, a series of tests for contaminants were undertaken as part of the
operations at Sites 801 and 1149.
To 185 Historical Perspectives
To 185 Table of Contents