Chronology of Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge Magmatism
Biostratigraphic studies of sediment directly overlying igneous basement
at Leg 183 sites provide minimum ages for the volcanic and volcaniclastic
rock. Middle Albian (~104.5-106.5 Ma) shallow-water sands and clays
overlie inflated pahoehoe flows at Site 1136, suggesting that the age of
the lavas is close to the ~110 Ma age of all other basalt samples
recovered to date from the SKP. Site 1138 on the CKP yielded
undifferentiated Upper Cretaceous claystone and sandstone on top of
igneous basement; these sediments are overlain by Cenomanian-Turonian
(~93.5 Ma) sandstone. This age is older than, but close to, the ~85 Ma date
for basalt at Site 747 (M.F. Coffin et al., unpubl. data). Drilling at the
conjugate Broken Ridge region (Site 1141; see Fig. 2) did not provide
useful minimum ages because the oldest sediment is Miocene, postdating
Eocene separation of Broken Ridge and the CKP and, therefore, much
younger than the formation age of Broken Ridge.
The first igneous basement ever recovered from Elan Bank at Site 1137 is
overlain by late Campanian (73.5-74.6 Ma) packstone. The lavas and
volcaniclastic sediments forming basement are likely to be somewhat
older, as the packstone is at the top of a basal sedimentary sequence that
thickens markedly to the east of Site 1137. Submarine igneous basement
of the NKP was cored for the first time at Site 1139 on Skiff Bank and
Site 1140 on the northernmost Kerguelen massif (Fig. 3). On Skiff Bank,
chalk at the base of the pelagic sedimentary section is earliest Oligocene
(32.8-34.3 Ma) in age. Igneous basement is probably older, as grainstone,
packstone, and sandstone lie between it and the overlying pelagic section.
Nevertheless, the minimum age is not inconsistent with the oldest rocks
from the Kerguelen Archipelago (Giret and Beaux, 1984; K.E. Nicolaysen et
al., unpubl. data). At Site 1140, lowermost Oligocene (34.3 Ma) pelagic
sediment directly overlies basement, and pelagic sediment of late Eocene
age (~35 Ma) is intercalated within basalt flows that form the uppermost
basement.
Petrogenesis of Basement Igneous Rocks
Except for Site 1139 on Skiff Bank (NKP), the dominant lava type at all
drill sites from diverse domains of the Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge
LIP are basalt with transitional to tholeiitic compositions (Fig. 19). These
basalts range in inferred age from Albian to early Oligocene and are from
the SKP (Sites 738, 749, 750, and 1136), Elan Bank (Site 1137), CKP (747
and 1138), NKP (1140), and Broken Ridge (Sites 1141 and 1142). The
basalts have relatively low MgO and Ni contents, and their compositions
are not similar to primary melts of peridotite. An example of the
important role for fractional crystallization in controlling the
compositions of these lavas are basalts from Site 1138, which show a
systematic downhole trend to Fe-Ti-rich basalt reaching TiO2
and total Fe2O3 contents of 3.2% and 19.2%,
respectively. In general, evolved tholeiitic basalt compositions are typical
of many flood basalts. The likely explanation is that the youngest magmas
in a LIP, like Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge, must ascend through
relatively thick lithosphere, thereby promoting cooling and partial
crystallization of the magma. Subsequent segregation of olivine- and
pyroxene-rich cumulates then forms the high velocity lower crust that is
typical of oceanic plateaus such as the Kerguelen Plateau (Charvis et al.,
1993, 1995; Operto and Charvis, 1995, 1996; Farnetani et al., 1996;
Könnecke et al., 1998; Charvis and Operto, 1999) and led to the
complementary evolved residual melts. In regard to this scenario, it is
important to realize that we have only sampled the upper 30-200 m of a
~20-km-thick mafic crust. The basement lavas at Site 1139 (Skiff Bank
on the NKP) are an exception to the previous generalization; they form an
alkaline lava series ranging from trachybasalt to trachyte and rhyolite;
the lowermost flow at Site 1139 is a trachyte (Figs. 34, 35). Similar
alkaline lava series have erupted in lower Miocene and
Pliocene/Pleistocene time in the Southeast Province of the Kerguelen
Archipelago (Weis et al., 1993, 1998; Frey et al., in press). The simplest
interpretation is that Skiff Bank, which reaches <500 m water depth, is a
submerged island analogous to but slightly older than the Kerguelen
Archipelago, also on the NKP but 350 km to the east-northeast (Fig.
3).
An important objective of Leg 183 was to evaluate the role of
continental crust in constructing the Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge LIP.
Previous evidence pointing to a significant role for continental crust in
diverse parts of the LIP includes isotopic and trace element abundance
data for basalts from the SKP (Site 738), CKP (Site 747), and basalts
dredged from the SKP and eastern Broken Ridge (Figs. 11, 12, 13; Storey et
al., 1989, 1992; Mahoney et al., 1995) and the seismic structure of the
crust in the northern part of the SKP (Operto and Charvis, 1995, 1996).
Some mantle xenoliths in the Kerguelen Archipelago lavas also show
evidence for a continental lithosphere component (Hassler and Shimizu,
1998; Mattielli et. al., 1999), as does a trachyte from Heard Island
(Barling et al., 1994). Drilling at Site 1137, however, recovered the
strongest evidence to date for a component of continental crust in the
Kerguelen Plateau. A ~26-m-thick fluvial conglomerate (Fig. 44)
intercalated with basaltic basement contains clasts of trachyte, rhyolite,
granitoid, and garnet biotite gneiss (Fig. 45); the garnet-biotite gneiss, in
particular, indicates that continental crustal rocks were once exposed at
Elan Bank. Furthermore, although it is difficult to use shipboard
geochemical data to identify continental material in mantle-derived
basaltic rocks, our study of Site 1137 cores builds a compelling case. The
basement basalts at Site 1137 are geochemically distinctive; they have
atypically high Zr/Y and Zr/Ti (Fig. 24) and a slight relative depletion in
Nb abundance (Figs. 24, 25)--both characteristics are consistent with a
component derived from continental crust.
A Nb/Y vs. Zr/Y plot has been used to distinguish between lavas derived
from the Icelandic plume and North Atlantic MORB (Fitton et al., 1997,
1998). In this plot (Fig. 31), it is important to realize that different
plumes are geochemically distinct; in particular, lavas of varying age,
from ~82 Ma to Pliocene-Pleistocene, associated with the Kerguelen
plume define a Nb/Y-Zr/Y trajectory along the lower boundary for the
Icelandic plume (Fig. 31). We conclude that the Kerguelen plume plots on
this line in the lower left portion of the figure. Basement basalts from
several locations on the Kerguelen Plateau (and Broken Ridge?) also lie
along this trend (namely, Sites 747, 1138, 1138, and 1140). Two other
locations are in the Icelandic field (Sites 749 and 750), and two others lie
in the MORB field (Sites 738 and 1137); however, basalts from these
latter two sites do not have MORB geochemical characteristics (Figs. 9,
25). We infer that basalts from Sites 738 and 1137 are in the MORB field
because they are plume-derived basalts that have been contaminated by
continental crust (Fig. 25). The effects of crustal contamination are
obvious in the Sr, Nd, and Pb isotopic characteristics of Site 738 basalts
(Figs. 9, 10). Isotopic data are not yet available for Site 1137 basalts, but
the clasts of garnet-biotite- gneiss in a conglomerate intercalated with
these basalts (Fig. 45) unambiguously show that continental crust is
present in the oceanic environment of Elan Bank.
Continental material, whether derived from continental crust or
subcrustal continental lithosphere, is occasionally incorporated into
oceanic lithosphere. At one end of the spectrum are microcontinents such
as Seychelles and Jan Mayen, which maintain normal continental crustal
thicknesses when isolated in ocean basins by jumps of seafloor spreading
centers, with or without involvement of mantle plumes. At the other end
of the spectrum are subtle geochemical signatures in otherwise typical
mid-ocean ridge basalts that have been interpreted to represent the
influence of deeply recycled continental material or subcrustal
continental lithosphere (e.g., Mahoney et al., 1996). As described above,
interpreted continental components of the Kerguelen Plateau and Broken
Ridge encompass a range of petrologic, geochemical, and geophysical
signatures and, therefore, may be accounted for by more than one process.
However, the simplest mechanism for incorporating continental material
into the Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge LIP is a ridge jump postdating the
breakup and initial seafloor spreading between India and Antarctica. One
or more ridge jumps to the north would have transferred continental parts
of the Indian plate to oceanic portions of the Antarctic plate, accounting
for features like Elan Bank and the portion of the SKP characterized by
continental crustal velocities. Published plate motion models (Fig. 2) do
not show any ridge jumps because the oceanic crust between Antarctic
and Kerguelen Plateau formed during the long Cretaceous Normal
Superchron and, therefore, is not datable using the usual technique of
marine magnetic anomaly identification. Nevertheless, the unambiguously
continental garnet-biotite gneiss recovered as clasts in a conglomerate
intercalated with basement basalt at Site 1137 on Elan Bank strongly
suggests that at least one northward ridge jump transferred a continental
fragment (Elan Bank) from the Indian to the Antarctic plate.
Environmental Impact of Kerguelen LIP Volcanism
Evidence from basalts and overlying sediments at Sites 738, 747, 748,
749, and 750 (Fig. 1), combined with results of subsidence modeling
(Coffin, 1992), shows that much of the igneous crust of the SKP and CKP
was erupted in a subaerial environment. Portions of the SKP remained
subaerial for as much as 50 m.y. after volcanism ceased. Leg 183 drilling
results corroborate, extend, and add detail to those previous results. On
the SKP (Site 1136), we cored upper bathyal to neritic sediment overlying
inflated pahoehoe lavas up to 20 m thick. The basalts lack features of
submarine volcanism (e.g., pillows and quenched glassy margins)
suggesting subaerial eruption. The CKP (Site 1138) was above sea level
during the final stages of construction; subaerial pyroclastic flow
deposits overlie ~5-m-thick subaerial lava flows ranging from inflated
pahoehoe to classic aa. Terrestrial and shallow marine sediment
containing wood fragments, a seed, spores, and pollen overlies igneous
basement, documenting for the first time that the CKP was subaerial after
volcanism ceased. In a conjugate position to the CKP, Broken Ridge
basaltic lavas were erupted in subaerial (Site 1141) and possibly
submarine (Site 1142) environments.
The igneous basement complex of Elan Bank at Site 1137 consists of seven
basaltic lava flows and three sedimentary units. Six of the seven 7- to
27-m-thick lava flows were erupted subaerially, as indicated by oxidation
zones and inflated pahoehoe characteristics, and the other may have
erupted into wet sediment. Some of the interbedded volcaniclastic
sedimentary rocks were deposited in a fluvial environment (braided river),
consistent with subaerial eruption of the basalts. Neritic packstones
overlying the igneous basement complex, in turn succeeded by pelagic
oozes, indicate gradual subsidence of Elan Bank.
Skiff Bank (Site 1139) was also subaerial during its final stages of
formation, as indicated by a succession of volcanic and volcaniclastic
rocks (some of which are oxidized) underlain by fourteen 2- to 20-m-thick
lava flows, including both pahoehoe and aa types. After volcanism ceased,
paleoenvironments of the overlying sediments changed intertidal (beach
deposits) to very high energy, near-shore (grainstone and sandstone) to
low-energy, offshore (packstone) to bathyal pelagic (ooze). In contrast,
igneous basement Site 1140 at the northernmost tip of the NKP consists
entirely of pillow basalts and intercalated pelagic sediment. However,
seafloor depths at all six other basement sites drilled during Leg 183 are
between 1000 and 2000 m, whereas Site 1140 is situated at a water
depth of 2450 m.
An unexpected result of Leg 183 drilling was the discovery that highly
evolved, felsic magmas were erupted explosively during the final stages
of magmatism over extensive regions of the Kerguelen Plateau. Igneous
basement recovered from four previous ODP sites on the SKP and CKP did
not include felsic lavas, but at four Leg 183 drill sites we recovered
pyroclastic flow deposits and dense lava samples of trachyte, dacite, and
quartz-bearing peralkaline rhyolite. Alkalic lavas have not been previously
recovered from the basement of the Kerguelen Plateau. At Site 748 on the
SKP, however, alkalic basalt was recovered from ~200 m above basement.
At Site 1137 on Elan Bank, a 15-m-thick sanidine-rich vitric tuff is
intercalated between basaltic lava flows. Well-preserved bubble wall
glass shards in part of the tuff together with abundant broken crystals
indicate that the tuff formed in an explosive volcanic eruption. Higher in
the stratigraphic sequence at Elan Bank, a fluvial conglomerate contains
clasts of rhyolitic and trachytic lavas. At Site 1138 on the CKP, we
recovered a 20-m-thick volcaniclastic succession containing six trachytic
pumice lithic breccias that were deposited by pyroclastic flows. This
volcaniclastic sequence also includes highly altered ash fall deposits that
contain accretionary lapilli. Above this sequence we recovered a reworked
deposit of rounded cobbles of flow-banded dacite. At Site 1139 on Skiff
Bank, which forms part of the NKP, the uppermost basement contains a
variety of felsic volcanic and volcaniclastic rocks. In contrast to the CKP
and Elan Bank sites, biostratigraphic ages of sediments directly overlying
this basement suggest that this episode of felsic volcanism is Cenozoic in
age. The Skiff Bank section includes densely welded pyroclastic flow
deposits of quartz-bearing peralkaline rhyolite, in addition to lava flows
and reworked cobbles of volcanic rock ranging from sanidine-rich trachyte
to rhyolite.
Evolved magmas (e.g., trachyte, phonolite, and peralkaline rhyolite) are
erupted during plume-related volcanism at oceanic islands and in some
continental flood basalt provinces (e.g., Parana, Etendeka, Karoo, and
Siberian Traps). Typically these eruptions occur near the end of
voluminous, basaltic magmatism. Two alternative modes of formation for
highly evolved magmas are partial melting of lower crustal rocks or as
residual magmas created as the supply of mantle derived basaltic magma
wanes, leading to formation of crustal-level magma chambers in which
highly evolved magma forms through crystal fractionation (±wallrock
assimilation) of basalt.
The eruption of enormous volumes of basaltic magma during formation of
the Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge LIP probably had significant
environmental consequences because of the release of volatiles such as
CO2, S, HCl, and HF. A key factor in the magnitude of volatile
release is whether the eruptions were subaerial or submarine; hydrostatic
pressure inhibits vesiculation and degassing of magma during submarine
eruptions. Results of Leg 183 drilling complement earlier results from
Legs 119 and 120 in demonstrating that subaerial basaltic eruptions
occurred during the final constructional stages of the plateau.
Another important factor that would have increased the environmental
consequences of Kerguelen Plateau-Broken Ridge LIP volcanism is the high
latitude at which the plateau formed. In most effusive basaltic eruptions,
released volatiles remain in the troposphere. However, at high latitudes,
the tropopause is relatively low, allowing large mass flux and basaltic
fissure eruption plumes to transport SO2 and other volatiles
into the stratosphere (e.g., 1783-1784 Laki eruption in Iceland). The
sulfuric acid aerosol particles that form in the stratosphere after such
eruptions have a longer residence time and greater global dispersal than if
the SO2 remains in the troposphere; therefore, they have
greater effects on climate and atmospheric chemistry. The large volume
and long duration of subaerial basaltic volcanism on the Kerguelen
Plateau-Broken Ridge LIP, combined with the high latitude of most of the
plateau, would all have contributed to potential environmental effects.
Highly explosive felsic eruptions, such as those that formed the
pyroclastic deposits on Elan Bank, Skiff Bank, and the CKP can also inject
both particulate material and volatiles (SO2,
CO2, possibly HCl) directly into the stratosphere. The
previously unrecognized, significant volume of explosive felsic volcanism
that occurred when the Kerguelen Plateau and Broken Ridge were subaerial
would have further contributed to the effects of this LIP volcanism on
global climate and environment. The total volume of felsic volcanic rocks
is still poorly constrained, but our results indicate that they account for a
significant fraction of the volcanic deposits erupted during the final
stages of magmatism at several locations on the Kerguelen Plateau.
Tectonic History
The uppermost volcanic basement of the Kerguelen Plateau was mostly
erupted in a subaerial environment (Leg 183 Sites 1136, 1137, 1138,
1139, and 1141; Leg 119 Site 738; Leg 120 Sites 747, 749, and 750),
although bathymetrically deeper basalts on the NKP (Site 1140) formed
under water. Sediments overlying basaltic basement at Leg 183 drill sites
record the vertical tectonic history of the Kerguelen Plateau through
changing facies. At Site 1136 on the SKP, neritic clay and sand overlie
basement, which are in turn overlain by pelagic chalk and ooze. This
sedimentary succession documents subsidence of the SKP since Early
Cretaceous time. On the CKP (Site 1138), terrestrial and shallow marine
sediment overlie basement. In particular, the transition from oxidized
neritic sediment to black claystone to pelagic sediment likely records
both thermal subsidence and eustatic sea level rise. At Site 1137 on Elan
Bank, fluvial sediment is interbedded with basalt, and neritic packstone
succeeded by pelagic ooze overlies volcanic basement. Despite a
component of continental crust in Elan Bank, its subsidence behavior
appears to resemble that of oceanic crust. The subsidence of Skiff Bank
(Site 1139), part of the NKP, is recorded by a transition from subaerial
(volcanic and volcaniclastic rocks) to intertidal (beach deposits) to very
high-energy, near-shore (grainstone and sandstone) to low-energy
offshore (packstone) to bathyal pelagic (ooze). In summary, during Leg 183
we recovered sediments that record subsidence of the SKP, CKP, Elan
Bank, and Skiff Bank; for the latter three sectors, these constitute the
first such records.
Postcruise Research
The basement rocks will be the focus of several shore-based studies; for
example: